Top 5 Black Commander Cards: Dominate With These Powerful Plays

Have you ever felt like you’re staring into the abyss, trying to build a Commander deck? Black decks can be super fun! They are known for their powerful spells and sneaky tricks. But choosing the right black cards can feel like navigating a dark, twisting maze. There are so many choices, it’s easy to get lost!

Picking the best black cards for Commander is tough. You have to think about your commander, your budget, and what kind of strategy you want to use. Do you want to drain life? Control the board? Or maybe just make your opponents discard their cards? Sorting through all the options can be overwhelming, wasting your time and making your deck less effective.

Don’t worry! This post will help you. We’ll break down the best black cards for Commander. You’ll learn about must-have staples, powerful removal spells, and cool creatures. By the end, you’ll have a clear idea of which black cards will make your deck a force to be reckoned with! So, let’s dive in and find the perfect cards to dominate your Commander games.

Our Top 5 Black Cards For Commander Recommendations at a Glance

Top 5 Black Cards For Commander Detailed Reviews

1. Magic: The Gathering Starter Commander Deck – Grave Danger (Blue-Black)

Magic: The Gathering Starter Commander Deck – Grave Danger (Blue-Black) | Ready-to-Play Deck for Beginners and Fans | Ages 13+ | Collectible Card Games

Rating: 8.5/10

Dive into the thrilling world of Magic: The Gathering with the Grave Danger Starter Commander Deck! This ready-to-play deck is perfect for both new players and seasoned fans. Command the blue-black colors, team up with Gisa and Geralf, and build an army of zombies to crush your opponents. This deck includes everything you need to start playing Commander, a fun multiplayer format. Get ready for epic battles and strategic gameplay with this awesome deck!

What We Like:

  • Ready to play right away! No need to build your own deck.
  • Great introduction to the Commander format. It’s easy to learn.
  • Features a 100-card blue-black deck with a zombie theme.
  • Includes a cool foil-etched legendary creature card.
  • Comes with a deck box, tokens, and counters.
  • A fun gift for anyone ages 13 and up.

What Could Be Improved:

  • The included strategy tips could be more detailed.
  • Availability of these decks might be limited.

The Grave Danger Starter Commander Deck is a fantastic way to start your Magic: The Gathering journey. It offers a fun and accessible way to learn the Commander format and enjoy the game with friends!

2. Magic: The Gathering Starter Commander Deck – Chaos Incarnate (Black-Red)

Magic: The Gathering Starter Commander Deck - Chaos Incarnate (Black-Red) | Ready-to-Play Deck for Beginners and Fans | Ages 13+ | Collectible Card Games

Rating: 9.0/10

Get ready to rumble with the Magic: The Gathering Starter Commander Deck – Chaos Incarnate (Black-Red)! This ready-to-play deck is perfect for new players and seasoned fans alike. It’s designed to jump right into the Commander format, a fun multiplayer way to play Magic. Unleash the power of black and red with the demon berserker Kardur, Doomscourge, as your commander. This deck is packed with cards to overwhelm your opponents. You can bring this game to a game night or local store.

What We Like:

  • Ready to play right away! No need to build a deck.
  • It’s a great way to learn the Commander format.
  • Includes a cool foil-etched legendary creature card!
  • Comes with a deck box and tokens for easy storage and play.
  • Fun for teens and adults. Makes a great gift!

What Could Be Improved:

  • Some players may want more complex strategies.
  • The deck might not be as powerful as more experienced players’ decks.

The Magic: The Gathering Starter Commander Deck – Chaos Incarnate (Black-Red) is a fantastic way to get started with Commander. It’s a fun and accessible entry point to the world of Magic: The Gathering!

3. Infinity Guard Card Deck Box for MTG

Infinity Guard Card Deck Box for MTG, Magic Commander Deck Box Fits 200+ Cards without Sleeves for TCG CCG Trading Cards (Black)

Rating: 8.5/10

The Infinity Guard Card Deck Box is a cool way to store your trading cards! This black deck box is made for Magic: The Gathering (MTG) and other card games. It can hold a lot of cards, even without sleeves. The box has a special design with the Black Lotus and magic elements. It’s made to look great while keeping your cards safe.

What We Like:

  • The design is awesome! It has a cool Black Lotus and magic symbols.
  • It’s made with strong PU leather that looks and feels great.
  • You can fit a lot of cards inside. It holds over 200 unsleeved cards!
  • It comes with dividers to help you organize your decks.
  • Strong magnets keep the box closed, so your cards won’t fall out.

What Could Be Improved:

  • It can’t hold cards with top loaders.

This Infinity Guard deck box is a fantastic choice for card game players. It keeps your cards safe and looks amazing while doing it. You will be happy with this purchase!

4. Magic the Gathering MTG Commander Collection: Black

Magic the Gathering MTG Commander Collection: Black

Rating: 8.7/10

The Magic the Gathering MTG Commander Collection: Black is a special box. It has eight reprinted cards. These cards are all about black, the color of tough choices and chances. This collection is made for Commander players. It includes powerful cards like Toxic Deluge, Ghoulcaller Gisa, and Phyrexian Arena. Black is known for its ability to control the battlefield and exploit opponents. This collection gives you some of the best black cards in one place.

What We Like:

  • The cards are powerful. They are great for Commander decks.
  • The collection focuses on one color. This makes it easy to see what black offers.
  • It includes some of black’s most iconic cards.

What Could Be Improved:

  • The price might be high for some players.
  • It only has eight cards, so it’s not a complete deck.

Overall, the Commander Collection: Black is a good buy for Commander players who like black. This collection provides key cards to help you dominate the game.

5. Black MTG Card Sleeves 200 Pack

Black MTG Card Sleeves 200 Pack, Standard Card Sleeves Sturdy MTG Matte Back Finish, Perfect Shuffling - Protect All Your Trading Collectible Cards by Fabmaker, Never Tear 66x91mm

Rating: 9.5/10

Protect your valuable trading cards with the Black MTG Card Sleeves by Fabmaker! This 200-pack of standard card sleeves is designed to keep your cards safe. They have a sturdy matte back finish that helps with shuffling. These sleeves are perfect for games like Magic: The Gathering, Digimon, and more. They’re made to last and keep your cards in great shape.

What We Like:

  • Sturdy Build: These sleeves are tough! They can handle lots of shuffling without ripping. They are thicker and stronger than other sleeves.
  • Easy Shuffling: The textured backs make shuffling easy. Your cards won’t slip or stick together.
  • Great for Many Games: These sleeves fit games like Magic: The Gathering, and others. They are perfect for showing off your cards and keeping them safe.
  • Fits Double Sleeved Cards: They are able to fit your cards in the binders, which is really great!
  • Protect Your Cards: They keep your cards safe from water and dust. They make your cards look nice and clean.

What Could Be Improved:

  • No specific cons.

Fabmaker’s Black MTG Card Sleeves are a great choice for any card game player. They keep your cards protected and easy to play with. Get these sleeves and keep your cards safe!

Black Cards for Commander: A Buying Guide

This guide helps you choose the best black cards for your Commander deck. Commander is a fun way to play Magic: The Gathering. You build a deck around a special card called your Commander. Black cards are powerful and often tricky. They can control the game and make your opponents worry!

Key Features to Look For

When picking black cards, think about what they do. Here are some key features:

  • Creature Removal: These cards destroy creatures. They stop your opponents from attacking. Look for cards like “Murder” or “Doom Blade.” They are simple and effective.
  • Card Draw: Black cards often let you draw extra cards. This gives you more options. You might pay life to draw cards. “Night’s Whisper” is a good example.
  • Discard: These cards make your opponents get rid of cards in their hand. This can mess up their plans. Cards like “Hymn to Tourach” are powerful, but sometimes cost a lot to play.
  • Life Drain: Black cards can take life from your opponents and give it to you. This helps you stay alive. “Vampire Nighthawk” is a good example.
  • Reanimation: These cards bring creatures back from the graveyard. You can reuse powerful creatures. “Reanimate” is a classic card for this.
  • Board Wipes: These cards get rid of everything on the board. It is good to reset the game. “Toxic Deluge” is one of the best.
Important Materials

The materials of your cards do not matter. All official Magic: The Gathering cards are made of the same material. They are made of paper. It is important to protect your cards. You should use card sleeves to keep them safe. This helps them from getting damaged.

Factors That Improve or Reduce Quality

Card quality is about how well the card looks and works. Here are some things to consider:

  • Rarity: Rarity does not always mean better. Rare cards are harder to find. They can be expensive. Common and uncommon cards can be very good too.
  • Price: Expensive cards are not always the best. Look for cards that fit your deck and your budget.
  • Condition: New cards are better. They have no scratches or wear. Used cards might be cheaper. Check the condition before you buy.
  • Set: Some sets have better black cards than others. Look at the cards in the set. See if they fit your Commander deck.
User Experience and Use Cases

Black cards are for players who like control. They are also good for players who like big creatures.

  • Control Decks: Use black cards to control the board. Get rid of your opponent’s creatures. Make them discard cards.
  • Combo Decks: Black cards help you find the cards you need. Draw extra cards and search your library.
  • Aggro Decks: Black cards can be used to remove blockers, and drain life from opponents.

Black cards are versatile. They can fit in many different types of Commander decks. Think about your play style. Choose cards that help you win.


Black Cards for Commander: Frequently Asked Questions

Q: What is the best black card for Commander?

A: There is no single “best” card. The best card depends on your deck and your play style. Many players like “Demonic Tutor.”

Q: What does “removal” mean in Magic: The Gathering?

A: “Removal” means getting rid of a card that your opponent controls. This could be a creature, an enchantment, or a land.

Q: Why are black cards good at drawing cards?

A: Black cards often let you draw cards at a cost. This cost is usually life. You pay life to get more cards.

Q: What does “board wipe” mean?

A: A “board wipe” is a card that gets rid of everything on the battlefield. It is like a reset button.

Q: How do I protect my black cards?

A: Use card sleeves to protect your cards from damage. Also, store your cards in a safe place, like a binder or deck box.

Q: Where can I buy black Commander cards?

A: You can buy cards at your local game store. You can also buy them online from many different websites.

Q: Are black cards always expensive?

A: No, many great black cards are cheap. Some of the most powerful cards are expensive, but not all.

Q: What is a “graveyard” in Magic: The Gathering?

A: The graveyard is where your discarded cards go. It is also where creatures die.

Q: Can I use black cards in any Commander deck?

A: You can use black cards in any Commander deck that includes black. Most Commander decks have one to two colors.

Q: What should I do if I don’t know a card’s rules?

A: Ask a judge or look up the card’s rules online. You can also ask a friend.

In conclusion, every product has unique features and benefits. We hope this review helps you decide if it meets your needs. An informed choice ensures the best experience.

If you have any questions or feedback, please share them in the comments. Your input helps everyone. Thank you for reading.

Leave a Comment